If you asked me when I first started to play fantasy baseball I couldn’t give you a correct answer. I have been playing fantasy baseball for so long that I can’t even remember when I first started. During all this time I’ve won my fair share of titles, and have come in the top three of countless others. On a few occasions I came in fifth out of twelve teams. That is because I lost several key starters to injuries that season and as a consequence I couldn’t recover to higher than fifth.
Do not think that competing in fantasy baseball is a piece of cake. The competition is brutal, the season is lengthy, other owners sometimes let their team go dormant, and in the worst cases, some owners collude with each other to win by not so fair means. So it may seem easy to play at first glance, but all in all competing in fantasy baseball can be tough.
Nothing beats the thrill that competing in fantasy baseball gives you. After all, despite all the downsides and the difficulties, you play to entertain yourself, to have fun. What could be more exciting than winning that first prize after a long season?
I thought long and hard about this and finally I decided to share with the rest of you some of my strategies for coming in first in fantasy baseball. Trust me, I didn’t arrive to this conclusion easily. I was so close to keeping my mouth shut, but contrary to my better judgment I decided to share. My main concern is making fantasy baseball more competitive across the board. The fact that some of you reading this may someday compete against me or the fact that one of my tougher league rivals may read this does not concern me. I just want to play, have fun, and win.
So what are we waiting for?
Let’s get started. Here is what I have done over the years and what has helped me win those elusive fantasy baseball titles:
- The most important part of any fantasy baseball session is the draft;
Yes, it’s true. The draft will make all the difference. You can recover from a poor draft, but it is better to not have to. In case of a poor draft you will need a lot of luck and a lot of other things to go your way in order to win the title.
Preparing for the draft is the most important thing that you can do. Now do not get me wrong, I am not telling you to go and read every chart known to man. A simple cheat sheet will do the trick. Sports Illustrated and ESPN offer such cheat sheets. Then make note of your league’s scoring system, and target players that fit into the system. Here’s a simple example: let’s say that your league awards four points for a homerun and one point for a stolen base. All you have to do is focus on the homerun hitters.
- Position scarcity;
Another key factor that you must take into consideration is position scarcity. Your draft plans must take into consideration if your league starts one catcher or two. Usually there is a big gap between the upper tier catchers, and the middle of the road catchers. In this case you may want to reach a little earlier in such a league. You are advised to go through each position and mark out where you think the drop offs are.
Personally I take each cheat sheet list by position, and draw a line at each level. I draw a line under the fourth player if I think the top tier guys are the first four at a position. During the draft if I see the top four players at that position going off the board, I know I can wait until later to pickup that position and focus on another position. Reaching for a position with lesser players when there are higher tier players available at another position is not advisable.
- Never draft a pitcher in the first round;
When it comes to drafting this is one rule that I always respect. Not many people out there will agree, and some may even call it an unwise decision. They may have a point, but I’ll tell you why I never draft a pitcher in the first round. If you go back through the last few years of drafts, more often than not, pitchers taken in the first round don’t pan out as well as the position players. There is no shortage of quality pitchers and you can wait on this position.
- Don’t get caught up in the emotion of a “run”;
During the drafting process avoid getting caught up in the emotion of a “run”. Beginners may not know what a run is, so I will explain. A run consists of three or more players at the same position being drafted one after another. A run occurs for a several reasons, such as the top tier is seen as drying up.
Make sure not to be fourth or fifth owner who gets involved in this. It may seem like a good idea at first, but most of the times the smart owner who lets everyone else panic draft, fills other draft holes with higher quality players. So pay attention.
- Closers must not be overvalued;
Ask anyone and they will all say the same thing: plenty of saves can be picked up form the waiver wire. They all say the same thing only because it is true. I thought it would be common knowledge by now, but is seems that there are still people that spend a fourth or fifth round pick on someone like Mariano Rivera. Usually closers are sporadic, so you should pick one at the opportune time, if you see good value.
Don’t overvalue closers and don’t waste a pick on a closer. You are better of drafting another player, a higher quality player. Lots of saves can be drafted in middle or late rounds.
- Stay up to date on injuries, trades, minor league call ups, etc.
Do not assume that you are done just because your draft is complete. You must also keep up with current events such as on injuries, trades, or minor league call ups. This way you can avoid starting a player that was injured and will not be able to play for months.
Be active, be informed. Make sure your starting pitchers are all going to pitch that week, and the hitters you start are regulars on their own team. Backup outfielders will not get you close to winning the title. - Stay on top of free agents in your league; You definitely do not want to be the owner that has to top waiver wire position and never uses it. Pay special attention to the free agents you choose. Do not pick them randomly, just for the sake of doing it. Some free agents fizzle out, others perform like champions, so you should make sure there is a balance. You can never know how things will go, but making an informed decision is the better way to go about it.
- Remember that having fun is the main objective.
The purpose of these fantasy baseball sessions is to entertain yourself, to have fun. Let’s say you drop a player and an opponent picks up that player. The player then has a great season, breaks all kinds of records. It’s ok to be upset, but do not get too caught up in this. Shake it off, the situation could have been reversed. Accidents like this one will always happen, even if you make and informed decision. The game would be thrilling if everything went as planned.
Remember that in the end it is a game, it is not a life or death matter. You are playing to have fun, and if you keep the advice I have given you in mind you may very well be the next fantasy baseball title winner.









